Is Using Nipple Shield Good for Breastfeeding? Pros and Cons
Posted on June 03, 2026
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- What is a Nipple Shield?
- When Using a Nipple Shield is Good for Breastfeeding
- How to Choose the Right Size
- The Correct Way to Apply a Nipple Shield
- Potential Challenges and Risks
- Protecting Your Milk Supply While Using a Shield
- Signs Your Baby is Getting Enough Milk
- Cleaning and Maintenance
- How to Wean Off a Nipple Shield
- When to Seek Professional Help
- Summary of Best Practices
- Conclusion
- FAQ
Introduction
Navigating the early days of breastfeeding can feel like a whirlwind of emotions and physical adjustments. You might find that your baby is struggling to latch, or perhaps you are dealing with significant nipple pain that makes every feeding session a challenge. In these moments, you may wonder: is using nipple shield good for breastfeeding, or will it create more problems down the road?
At Milky Mama, we know that every drop of breast milk counts and that the right tools can make your feeding journey much more sustainable. If you need extra one-on-one support, our Certified Lactation Consultant Breastfeeding Help page is a helpful next step. This article explores the specific situations where a nipple shield is a helpful bridge, how to use one correctly, and the steps you can take to protect your milk supply while using tools. We believe that breastfeeding is natural, but it does not always come naturally, and having the right information helps you feel empowered. (milky-mama.com)
Using a nipple shield can be a highly effective temporary solution for latching difficulties when it is implemented with professional guidance and the correct technique.
What is a Nipple Shield?
A nipple shield is a thin, flexible silicone tool shaped like a small hat. The center part, or the "crown," fits over your nipple, while the wide brim rests against your areola. Most modern shields have tiny holes at the tip to allow breast milk to flow through into your baby's mouth.
These tools serve as a firm, steady target for your baby. Because the silicone is firmer than human skin, it provides a stronger stimulus to the roof of the baby’s mouth. This stimulus can trigger the sucking reflex in infants who are sleepy or struggling to find their way. For a broader breastfeeding foundation, our Breastfeeding 101 course walks through latching, milk supply, and common early feeding questions. (milky-mama.com)
While older versions of shields were thick and could interfere with milk supply, modern silicone shields are incredibly thin. They are designed to allow for as much skin-to-skin contact as possible while still providing a functional surface for the baby to grasp.
When Using a Nipple Shield is Good for Breastfeeding
There are several specific scenarios where a nipple shield is not just "good" but can be the very tool that saves a breastfeeding relationship. It is often used as a temporary bridge to help a baby learn the mechanics of nursing.
Flat or Inverted Nipples
Some parents have nipples that do not naturally protrude or that tuck inward when stimulated. For a newborn, this can make it difficult to feel the "trigger point" at the roof of the mouth that tells them to suck. A nipple shield provides a consistent shape that allows the baby to latch on easily, regardless of the nipple's natural anatomy.
Premature Babies
Infants born early often have smaller mouths and weaker muscle tone. They may tire quickly or struggle to maintain a deep latch. The firmness of the shield helps a premature baby keep the breast in their mouth with less effort, allowing them to receive more milk directly from the breast rather than relying solely on bottles or tubes.
Transitioning from Bottle to Breast
If a baby has become accustomed to the firm, consistent flow of a bottle teat, they may experience "nipple confusion" or "nipple preference." The silicone shield feels more familiar to a bottle-fed baby, making them more willing to attempt nursing. This can be a vital step in helping a baby return to the breast after a period of separation or supplementation.
Severe Nipple Damage
While a shield should not be used to "mask" a poor latch indefinitely, it can act like a protective glove for parents dealing with cracked, bleeding, or extremely sore nipples. It allows the tissue to heal by reducing the direct friction of the baby’s tongue while still allowing the nursing relationship to continue.
Oral Anatomy Challenges
Babies with a high palate, a receding jaw, or certain degrees of tongue-tie may find it difficult to wrap their tongue around the breast tissue effectively. The shield helps bridge that gap, giving the baby a more stable surface to compress.
Key Takeaway: A nipple shield is a therapeutic tool meant to assist with specific latching challenges, providing a firm stimulus that helps infants nurse more effectively.
How to Choose the Right Size
One of the most common reasons parents have a negative experience with nipple shields is using the wrong size. If the shield is too small, it can rub against your nipple and cause further damage. If it is too large, the baby may take in too much air or struggle to compress the breast.
Nipple shields are typically measured in millimeters (mm), referring to the diameter of the nipple cone. Standard sizes often include 16mm, 20mm, and 24mm. If you want a deeper dive into how milk removal and feeding frequency affect supply, our article on how breast milk supply works is a useful companion. (milky-mama.com)
To find your size:
- Measure the diameter of your nipple at the base (where it meets the areola).
- Your nipple should fit comfortably inside the cone without touching the sides during a feeding.
- There should be a small gap at the tip of the shield when your nipple is fully drawn in.
If you are unsure, we recommend consulting with a certified lactation consultant to ensure the fit is perfect for your specific anatomy.
The Correct Way to Apply a Nipple Shield
Applying a shield is not as simple as just placing it on top of the breast. To ensure it stays in place and helps the baby get a deep latch, you should use the "inside-out" method.
- Moisten the brim: Use a little bit of warm water or breast milk around the edges of the shield to help it "suction" to your skin.
- Flip the brim: Hold the shield by the base and use your thumbs to flip the brim halfway inside out.
- Center your nipple: Place the tip of the shield directly over your nipple.
- Roll it down: As you release the brim, it should roll down over your areola, gently drawing your nipple further into the cone.
- Check the fit: Your nipple should be centered and pulled into the cone, but it should not be touching the very end of the shield before the baby starts sucking.
What to do next:
- Watch for the "flanged" lip look on your baby.
- Listen for audible swallows during the feed.
- Ensure the shield does not "pucker" or collapse during the session.
Potential Challenges and Risks
While using a nipple shield can be good for breastfeeding in the short term, it is important to be aware of the potential downsides.
Reduced Milk Transfer
Because there is a layer of silicone between the baby and the breast, some infants may not be able to remove milk as efficiently as they would with a direct latch. This can sometimes lead to the baby getting less milk during a session, which may result in slower weight gain if not monitored.
Impact on Milk Supply
Your body produces milk based on "supply and demand." If the nipple shield prevents the baby from fully draining the breast, your body may receive a signal to slow down production. This is why many lactation experts recommend expressing milk after a session if you are using a shield full-time.
Risk of Mastitis
If the breast is not being emptied effectively, milk can back up in the ducts. This increase in pressure can lead to clogged ducts or mastitis, an inflammation of the breast tissue. If you notice red, warm, or painful lumps in your breast, contact your healthcare provider immediately.
Latch Dependency
Some babies become very used to the feel of the shield and may refuse to latch onto the bare breast. This can make weaning off the shield a long process that requires patience and persistence.
Protecting Your Milk Supply While Using a Shield
If you are using a nipple shield, it is vital to take proactive steps to ensure your milk supply remains robust. Since the shield may slightly reduce the stimulation your body receives, you can use other methods to keep your supply high.
We often suggest incorporating herbal support and nourishing snacks to help bridge the gap. For many parents, our Lady Leche or Pump Hero capsules may support a healthy milk flow and supply. (milky-mama.com)
This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Consult with your healthcare provider for medical advice.
In addition to supplements, consider these strategies:
- Breast Compressions: While your baby is nursing, gently squeeze your breast to help move more milk toward the nipple.
- Skin-to-Skin Contact: Spend plenty of time holding your baby chest-to-chest. This releases oxytocin, the hormone responsible for the let-down reflex (the process that releases milk from the ducts).
- Pumping: If your baby is not draining the breast well, use a pump for 10–15 minutes after a nursing session to ensure the breast is empty.
Our Emergency Lactation Brownies are another favorite among the Milky Mama community, and they sit inside our lactation snacks collection for parents who want a convenient treat during demanding feeding days. (milky-mama.com)
Signs Your Baby is Getting Enough Milk
When using any tool, the most important factor is your baby’s health and growth. You can feel confident that the nipple shield is working well if you see the following signs:
- Wet and Dirty Diapers: Your baby should have at least six heavy wet diapers and multiple bowel movements every 24 hours (once they are past the first week of life).
- Swallowing: You should be able to hear a "kuh" sound or see a deep jaw drop that indicates the baby is swallowing milk.
- Softening Breasts: Your breasts should feel noticeably softer and lighter after a feeding session.
- Weight Gain: Your baby should continue to follow their growth curve at pediatric check-ups.
Key Takeaway: Monitoring diaper output and weight gain is the best way to ensure that using a nipple shield is supporting your baby's nutrition effectively.
Cleaning and Maintenance
Because nipple shields are made of silicone, they can harbor bacteria if not cleaned properly.
After every single use, wash the shield in hot, soapy water. Rinse it thoroughly with clean water and allow it to air dry on a clean surface. It is also a good idea to sterilize the shield once a day by boiling it in water for five minutes or using a steam sterilization bag.
Store your clean, dry shield in a breathable container. Avoid keeping it in a sealed plastic bag while it is still damp, as this can encourage the growth of mold or yeast (thrush).
How to Wean Off a Nipple Shield
For most families, the goal is eventually to return to breastfeeding without the shield. This process should be gradual and stress-free for both you and your baby.
The Mid-Feed Swap
Start the feeding session with the nipple shield. Once your milk has let down and the baby is settled into a rhythm, gently break the suction and remove the shield. Try to latch the baby onto the bare breast while they are already in a "sucking" headspace.
The Sleepy Latch
Babies are often more willing to try new things when they are slightly sleepy. Try offering the bare breast during a nighttime feeding or right as the baby is waking up from a nap.
Skin-to-Skin Opportunities
Spend time with your baby "hanging out" near your breasts without the pressure of a feeding. Let them explore, smell, and nuzzle the area. This can help them become more comfortable with the sensation of your skin versus the silicone.
Be Patient
Some babies wean off the shield in a day, while others take weeks or months. Both scenarios are okay. If your baby gets frustrated, put the shield back on and try again during the next session. We want the breast to remain a "happy place" for your little one. If supply support is still a concern during this phase, our lactation supplements collection can be an easy place to browse options. (milky-mama.com)
When to Seek Professional Help
While a nipple shield can be a great temporary tool, it is not a substitute for skilled lactation support. If you find yourself reaching for a shield, it is a sign that there is an underlying challenge that needs to be addressed.
You should contact an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC) if:
- Breastfeeding remains painful even with the shield.
- Your baby is not gaining weight or having enough wet diapers.
- You are unable to get the baby to latch even with the shield.
- You feel like your milk supply is decreasing.
- You are struggling to wean off the shield and feel overwhelmed.
Working with a professional can help you identify the root cause of the latch issue, whether it is a positioning problem, a physical tie, or an anatomical variation. Our Breastfeeding 101 course and how to have a good breast milk supply guide can also give you more education while you troubleshoot. (milky-mama.com)
Summary of Best Practices
If you decide to use a nipple shield, keep these steps in mind to ensure success:
- Ensure you have the correct size (mm) for your nipple.
- Apply the shield using the inside-out method for a deeper latch.
- Monitor your baby’s output (diapers) and weight gain closely.
- Express milk if needed to protect your supply.
- Clean and sterilize the shield daily.
- Work with a lactation consultant to address the underlying latch issue.
Conclusion
Is using nipple shield good for breastfeeding? The answer is a resounding "yes" when it is used as a temporary bridge to overcome specific challenges. It can help babies with flat nipples, premature infants, and those transitioning from bottles to find success at the breast. However, it is a tool that requires careful monitoring to ensure your milk supply stays protected and your baby stays well-fed.
- A nipple shield provides a firm target for babies who struggle to latch.
- Proper sizing and application are essential for comfort and milk flow.
- Protecting your supply with pumping or supplements is often necessary.
- Weaning should be a gradual, patient process.
"Your breastfeeding journey is unique. Whether you use a shield for a week or your entire journey, what matters most is the bond you are building and the nourishment you are providing."
If you need extra support for your milk supply while navigating latch challenges, our finding the right resources for breastfeeding guide can help you decide whether education, supplements, or direct support is the best next step. You're doing an amazing job. (milky-mama.com)
FAQ
Can using a nipple shield cause my milk supply to drop?
It can potentially cause a drop in supply if the baby is not removing milk efficiently, as your body relies on the "emptying" of the breast to signal more production. To prevent this, many parents use a breast pump after nursing sessions to ensure the breasts are fully drained.
Is it okay to use a nipple shield if I have sore nipples?
A nipple shield can provide temporary relief from the pain of cracked or sore nipples by acting as a protective barrier. However, it is important to find the root cause of the soreness—usually a poor latch—to ensure long-term comfort and successful breastfeeding.
How do I know if the nipple shield is the right size?
The shield is the right size if your nipple fits comfortably inside the cone without rubbing against the sides during a feed. There should also be a small space between the tip of your nipple and the end of the silicone cone to allow for the nipple to expand and milk to pool.
How long should I use a nipple shield?
There is no set timeline, as some families use them for a few days while others use them for months. The general recommendation is to use it as a temporary bridge and work toward weaning once the underlying latch issue is resolved and the baby is growing well.
Bestsellers
Emergency Lactation Brownies
Regular price
From $51.00 CAD
Regular price
Sale price
From $51.00 CAD
Unit price
per
$45.90 CAD
Subscribe & Save: 10% off
SHOP NOW
Lady Leche
Regular price
$39.00 CAD
Regular price
Sale price
$39.00 CAD
Unit price
per
$35.10 CAD
Subscribe & Save: 10% off
SHOP NOW
Bestseller Bundle
Regular price
$138.00 CAD
Regular price
Sale price
$138.00 CAD
Unit price
per
$124.20 CAD
Subscribe & Save: 10% off
SHOP NOW
Pump Hero
Regular price
$32.00 CAD
Regular price
Sale price
$32.00 CAD
Unit price
per
$28.80 CAD
Subscribe & Save: 10% off
SHOP NOW
